I had seen the below a number of times on eBay and stumbled across a copy at my old job at one point as well. I always assumed it was an '80s or newer commemorative issue, maaaaybe '70s at best. I was pleasantly surprised when I stumbled across a PSA graded listing on eBay with the actual date as 1958. I snagged it as quickly as I could and recently got it back after submitting it at work.
All that being said, I actually disagree with the card being a 1958 as the back clearly states "Named to Hall of Fame, 1969.