The Everton defender foolishly handled the ball as it seemed destined for goal — resulting in a sending off and the game-tying goal.
Everton thought it had pulled off a dramatic victory at Old Trafford on Tuesday, until Ashley Williams' ill-advised clearance attempt deep into stoppage time resulted in a penalty kick for Manchester United.
The Merseysiders were leading 1-0 until the third minute of stoppage time, when Williams' failed attempt at a header ended up being a hand ball near the top of the 6-yard box — which meant United was awarded a spot kick and the Welsh defender was shown a red card.