One thing we do know about the Yankees outfield heading into next season is that All-Star Aaron Judge will be back in right field and Aaron Hicks will be back in center looking to build off of a career season in 2018. Also, Giancarlo Stanton will continue to be the primary DH and fill in when needed at either corner outfield spot.
When the Yankees acquired McCutchen for the September stretch run this past season he turned out to be an outstanding leadoff man, but it’s likely he’ll sign elsewhere this winter. McCutchen isn’t the perennial MVP candidate he once was but he’s still a very productive player at 32 years old and he should get some multi-year offers with a $12-15 million average salary.