Jay Cutler has been called a lot of things during his seven years with the Chicago Bears. Some good, some bad, but the topic of "Cutler" always sparked a reaction from Bears' fans. He had some baggage coming in, mostly because it was perceived that he forced a trade out of Denver, but also because he was an arrogant young player. Then he struggled as he tried to carry the Chicago offense that first year (2009), and some fans soured on him even more.
The narrative has slightly changed through the years, but some of that has been based on the team's success.